This is all speculation. Not the Johnny part but leaving pregnant.

As someone who is a die hard Lumi fan, I’m actually not in favour of retconning Johnny as a Horton. Sami having twins with two different men had so much potential for long term storylines. Yes, I know she has Sydney from EJ, but this feels… off? It’s kind of like the EJami years were all for naught.

Agreed, I’ve always liked that Johnny & Allie are twins with such different fathers & Johnny being a Dimera & a Brady has way more potential storylines.

I would have been thrilled if Johnny were revealed to be Lucas’s ~15 years ago. Now? Nah. Sami has four grown children split between two men — why disrupt that NOW?!?

Profile Badge for the Achievement Top 1% Commenter Top 1% Commenter
The article, in spite of starting out by saying there are leaks about the story, does not quote anyone or any piece of evidence. It read like PURE speculation and it wasn’t even written well. I hope that we have a really cool twist and the story lets Ali shine, but retconning Johnny as Lucas’ son now would be dumb IMO. It doesn’t change the fact that EJ is a rapist and it does leave a generational hole in the Dimeras which doesn’t seem useful.

Johnny should have found out about his conception when he was reading the script of Will’s “The Sami Brady Story”. I was begging for that storyline every time Johnny was reading the script.

I hope she didn’t have an off-camera baby. Keeping that baby secret from her parents and its siblings for years when they’ve been so present on the canvas — no thanks.

I’m ok about retconning Johnny, maybe. I don’t particularly care about his tie to dimera and Lucas is one of my favorite actors — giving him more screen time suits me.